Pizza in the Prairie: Discovering North Dakota’s Unexpected Slice Scene

North Dakota’s Bright Future: Celebrating Positive Developments Across the Peace Garden State

North Dakota, with its vast open plains and friendly communities, might not be the first state that comes to mind when you think of pizza. However, this hidden gem of the Midwest is home to a vibrant and unique pizza culture that blends classic recipes with local flair. From farm-fresh ingredients to creative adaptations, pizza in North Dakota is a testament to the state’s innovative spirit and deep culinary roots.

In this article, we’ll explore the standout pizzerias, quirky stories, festivals, and flavors that make North Dakota’s pizza scene worth celebrating. Whether you’re a lifelong resident or a curious traveler, North Dakota proves that great pizza can thrive in even the most unexpected places.

A Brief History of Pizza in North Dakota

Pizza made its way to North Dakota through European immigrants and the post-World War II boom in Italian-American cuisine. Early adopters brought their recipes to small towns and cities, adapting traditional techniques to the state’s abundant agricultural resources.

Wheat fields and dairy farms provided the perfect base for fresh crusts and rich cheeses, while the state’s love for hearty, comforting food ensured pizza quickly became a local favorite. Over time, pizzerias in North Dakota began to experiment with regional flavors, giving rise to unique styles that highlight the state’s agricultural heritage.

Top Pizzerias in North Dakota

1. Rhombus Guys (Fargo & Grand Forks)

North Dakota Wines & Wineries-Badlands

Rhombus Guys is a standout on North Dakota’s pizza map, offering an eclectic menu and a fun, laid-back atmosphere. Their creative pizzas include the “T-Rex” (loaded with five types of meat) and the “Thai Chicken Pizza,” featuring a sweet and tangy peanut sauce. Their rooftop patio in Fargo is the perfect spot to enjoy a slice on a sunny day.

Website: Rhombus Guys

2. Spicy Pie (Multiple Locations)

Spicy Pie started as a small pizza joint in Fargo and has grown into a beloved regional chain. Known for its oversized New York-style slices and quirky vibe, Spicy Pie offers everything from classic pepperoni to unique creations like the “Taco Pizza,” topped with seasoned beef, lettuce, and tortilla chips.

Website: Spicy Pie

3. Fireflour Pizza + Coffee Bar (Bismarck)

For an upscale experience, head to Fireflour Pizza in Bismarck. This artisan pizzeria specializes in Neapolitan-style pies made with locally sourced ingredients. The “Prosciutto Arugula Pizza,” with fresh arugula, thinly sliced prosciutto, and Parmesan, is a must-try. Their coffee bar is an added bonus.

Website: Fireflour Pizza

4. The Broken Brick (Dickinson)

The Broken Brick offers a cozy, hometown feel with its wood-fired pizzas and welcoming ambiance. Known for their “Dakota Pizza,” featuring locally made sausage and fresh vegetables, this pizzeria captures the essence of North Dakota in every bite.

Website: The Broken Brick

5. Sammy’s Pizza (Minot)

North Dakota Weddings-Buffalo

Sammy’s Pizza is a family-owned chain with roots going back to the 1950s. Their Minot location has become a community favorite, serving classic thin-crust pizzas with generous toppings. Their sausage and mushroom pizza is a crowd-pleaser.

Website: Sammy’s Pizza

Pizza Festivals in North Dakota

Fargo Pizza Fest

Fargo’s Pizza Fest is a celebration of the city’s diverse pizza scene, featuring local pizzerias, food trucks, and live music. Guests can sample a wide variety of pizzas, from traditional to experimental, and vote for their favorite.

Learn more: Visit Fargo

North Dakota State Fair (Minot)

While not solely dedicated to pizza, the North Dakota State Fair features numerous food vendors offering creative pizza options, including Midwest-inspired takes like corn and bacon pizzas. It’s a great way to enjoy a slice while taking in the fair’s attractions.

Learn more: North Dakota State Fair

Taste of Bismarck

This annual food festival highlights local cuisine, including some of the city’s top pizza spots. Attendees can enjoy pizza tastings, live entertainment, and a family-friendly atmosphere.

Learn more: Taste of Bismarck

Famous Pizza Stories in North Dakota

1. Rhombus Guys’ Pizza Bus

North Dakota Beers & Breweries-Small canyon in the plains

Before becoming a beloved brick-and-mortar establishment, Rhombus Guys started as a mobile pizza operation in a converted bus. This innovative start paved the way for their success and reflects the entrepreneurial spirit of North Dakota.

2. Spicy Pie’s Taco Pizza Craze

Spicy Pie’s Taco Pizza has become a regional icon, blending two comfort food favorites into one delicious creation. Its popularity has earned it a cult following, and it’s a staple at local events and gatherings.

3. Fireflour’s Local Commitment

Fireflour Pizza’s dedication to sourcing local ingredients has set a new standard for quality in North Dakota’s pizza scene. Their partnerships with local farmers and producers ensure that every pie is fresh, flavorful, and a true representation of the region.

Signature Pizza Styles in North Dakota

Pizza in North Dakota often incorporates elements that reflect the state’s agricultural bounty and hearty food preferences. Here are some standout styles and toppings:

Taco Pizza: A favorite across the state, featuring seasoned beef, shredded lettuce, diced tomatoes, cheddar cheese, and tortilla chips.
Midwestern Meats Pizza: Loaded with locally sourced sausages, bacon, and pepperoni, this style caters to meat lovers.
Corn and Bacon Pizza: Highlighting sweet corn and crispy bacon, this combination celebrates two of North Dakota’s staple ingredients.
Neapolitan-Inspired Pies: Artisan pizzerias like Fireflour embrace the simplicity of wood-fired Neapolitan-style pizzas, focusing on fresh ingredients and authentic techniques.

The Future of Pizza in North Dakota

Foods Of North Dakota-Mountain Goat

As North Dakota continues to grow and diversify, its pizza scene is evolving in exciting ways. Chefs and pizzerias are experimenting with gluten-free crusts, plant-based toppings, and international flavors, appealing to a wider audience. Food trucks and pop-up pizzerias are also gaining traction, bringing creative pizza options to festivals, farmers’ markets, and community events.

Plan Your North Dakota Pizza Tour

A pizza tour through North Dakota is an adventure in flavor and community. Start in Fargo with Rhombus Guys and Spicy Pie, then head west to Bismarck for Fireflour Pizza. Make your way to Dickinson to visit The Broken Brick, and don’t forget to stop in Minot for a slice at Sammy’s Pizza. Along the way, you’ll experience the state’s warm hospitality and unique take on this universally loved dish.

Conclusion: A Slice of North Dakota’s Charm

Pizza in North Dakota reflects the state’s innovative spirit, strong community ties, and agricultural heritage. Whether you’re savoring a classic thin-crust pie or a creative taco pizza, every bite tells a story of local pride and culinary creativity. From bustling city pizzerias to small-town gems, North Dakota proves that great pizza isn’t limited to the coasts—it’s thriving right here in the heart of the Midwest.

Next time you find yourself in the Peace Garden State, make sure to explore its pizza scene. You’ll not only discover delicious flavors but also experience the warmth and charm that make North Dakota truly special.

Related Links: