New York Pizza: A Slice of Perfection in the Empire State

New York Wineries

New York and pizza are inseparable. From its iconic thin-crust, foldable slices to artisanal wood-fired creations, New York has earned its reputation as the pizza capital of the world. A visit to the Empire State isn’t complete without indulging in its legendary pies, which have become as much a cultural emblem as the Statue of Liberty or Times Square. Whether it’s a late-night dollar slice in Manhattan or a meticulously crafted Neapolitan pie in Brooklyn, New York offers a pizza experience like no other.

In this article, we’ll take a deep dive into the history, notable pizzerias, festivals, and famous pizza stories that define New York’s rich pizza heritage. From classic corner shops to innovative newcomers, here’s everything you need to know about pizza in New York.

The History of Pizza in New York

The story of New York pizza begins in the late 19th century, with the arrival of Italian immigrants to the United States. In 1905, Gennaro Lombardi opened Lombardi’s in Manhattan’s Little Italy, earning it the title of America’s first pizzeria. Using a coal-fired oven and simple, high-quality ingredients, Lombardi’s introduced Neapolitan-style pizza to New York, quickly making it a local favorite.

As the city grew, so did its pizza culture. By the mid-20th century, New York-style pizza—a thinner, wider variation of the Neapolitan classic—became the norm. With its chewy crust, vibrant tomato sauce, and gooey mozzarella cheese, New York pizza became a culinary phenomenon, inspiring countless imitations worldwide.

Top Pizzerias in New York

1. Lombardi’s (Manhattan)

Positive Things In New York

Known as America’s first pizzeria, Lombardi’s is a must-visit for pizza enthusiasts. Their coal-fired pies, especially the classic Margherita, set the standard for New York pizza. The nostalgic ambiance and historic significance make every visit special.

Website: Lombardi’s Pizza

2. Di Fara Pizza (Brooklyn)

Located in Midwood, Brooklyn, Di Fara Pizza is a pilgrimage site for pizza lovers. The late Domenico DeMarco handcrafted every pie with care, using imported Italian ingredients. Their signature pie, topped with basil and olive oil, is legendary.

Website: Di Fara Pizza

3. Joe’s Pizza (Manhattan)

Joe’s Pizza in Greenwich Village has been serving classic New York slices since 1975. Their perfect balance of thin crust, rich tomato sauce, and gooey cheese has earned them a loyal following and appearances in numerous films.

Website: Joe’s Pizza

4. Patsy’s Pizzeria (East Harlem)

A pioneer in coal-oven pizza, Patsy’s has been a staple of East Harlem since 1933. Their thin-crust pizzas, particularly the white pie, are beloved by locals and tourists alike.

Website: Patsy’s Pizzeria

5. Roberta’s (Brooklyn)

This Bushwick hotspot combines a hip vibe with wood-fired pizza perfection. Roberta’s “Bee Sting,” featuring spicy soppressata and honey, exemplifies their innovative approach to pizza.

Website: Roberta’s

6. Prince Street Pizza (Manhattan)

New York Weddings

Famous for their thick, square-shaped pepperoni slices, Prince Street Pizza is a favorite for those seeking a heartier option. Their Spicy Spring pie, with crispy pepperoni cups, is a crowd-pleaser.

Website: Prince Street Pizza

Pizza Festivals in New York

New York Pizza Festival (Bronx)

The New York Pizza Festival is an annual celebration of the city’s pizza culture, featuring top pizzerias from all five boroughs. Attendees can sample slices, watch live pizza-making demos, and enjoy live music. Proceeds often benefit local charities.

Learn more: New York Pizza Festival

Slice Out Hunger Pizza Party (Manhattan)

This charity event gathers New York’s best pizzerias under one roof, offering $1 slices to support hunger relief efforts. It’s an affordable and delicious way to try pizzas from multiple iconic establishments.

Learn more: Slice Out Hunger

Brooklyn Pizza Fest

A local favorite, this festival showcases Brooklyn’s top pizzerias alongside craft beer, live music, and fun activities. It’s a great way to experience the borough’s diverse pizza styles.

Learn more: Brooklyn Pizza Fest

Famous Pizza Stories in New York

1. The Rise of the Dollar Slice

New York Foods

New York’s famous dollar slice joints emerged in the early 2000s, offering budget-friendly options for late-night crowds. Spots like 2 Bros Pizza became synonymous with the city’s fast-paced, no-frills lifestyle, proving that great pizza doesn’t have to be expensive.

2. The Mafia and Pizza Connection

In the 1980s, a federal investigation dubbed the “Pizza Connection” revealed that mafia families used pizzerias as fronts for drug trafficking. The case highlighted how deeply pizza was embedded in New York’s social and economic fabric.

3. The Roberta’s Revolution

Roberta’s in Brooklyn redefined New York’s pizza scene by blending traditional techniques with modern creativity. Their focus on locally sourced ingredients and innovative flavors has inspired a new generation of pizzerias.

4. Di Fara’s $5,000 Pizza Auction

In 2019, Di Fara Pizza auctioned a pizza for $5,000 as part of a charity event, cementing its reputation as one of the most revered pizzerias in the world.

Signature New York Pizza Styles

New York’s pizza diversity is unmatched. Here are the most iconic styles you’ll find across the state:

Classic New York-Style Pizza: Thin, foldable crust, tangy tomato sauce, and gooey mozzarella cheese.
Grandma Pie: A thin, square pie with a crisp crust, often topped with tomato sauce and fresh mozzarella.
Sicilian Pizza: Thick and square, with a fluffy crust and generous layers of sauce and cheese.
Coal-Oven Pizza: Charred crust and simple toppings, cooked in high-temperature coal-fired ovens.
Artisan Neapolitan Pizza: Wood-fired and made with fresh, high-quality ingredients, often featuring creative toppings.

The Future of Pizza in New York

New York City 911 Memory

New York’s pizza scene is constantly evolving. Sustainability is becoming a priority, with more pizzerias sourcing local and organic ingredients. Gluten-free and vegan options are also gaining popularity, ensuring that everyone can enjoy a slice. Additionally, food trucks and pop-up pizzerias are bringing high-quality pies to new neighborhoods and events.

Plan Your New York Pizza Adventure

A pizza tour in New York is a culinary journey through history and innovation. Begin in Manhattan with classics like Lombardi’s and Joe’s, then head to Brooklyn for Di Fara and Roberta’s. Don’t forget to explore the Bronx and Queens, where hidden gems like Louie & Ernie’s Pizza and New Park Pizza await. Cap off your adventure with a visit to one of the city’s pizza festivals for the ultimate experience.

Conclusion: The Heart of Pizza Culture

New York pizza is more than just food—it’s a cultural icon, a shared experience, and a slice of the city’s soul. From historic pizzerias that helped define American pizza to modern innovators pushing the boundaries of what a pie can be, New York’s pizza scene is unparalleled. Whether you’re grabbing a quick dollar slice or savoring an artisanal creation, every bite is a testament to the city’s love affair with pizza. So, when you visit the Empire State, make sure to take a delicious journey through its legendary pizza landscape.

Related Links: